Let's rate those players

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Kamuza
Kamuza
International Call-Up
International Call-Up
Posts : 973
User Points : 4084
Posting Flair : 832
Join date : 2012-06-22

PostKamuza Sun Sep 30, 2012 6:35 am

Marshall - I don't remember Blackpool having a shot on target so I'll assume he knew that free kick was going to hit the post and that's way it looked like it had him beaten all ways up. - 7

McNauhgton - Blackpool are a tough team for any full back to play and Ince being out made Super-Kev's day a bit easier than it might have been. One piece of classic McNaughton covering and some nice support of the attack - 7

Connolly - You score twice you get a good rating but today Connolly looked the equal of Hudson as a defender. Very good performance. - 9

Hudson - it is a bit daft to get booked in the last minute of 3-0 win. The clean sheet bonus must be good. - 7

Taylor - Malky singled him out for praise and who am I to disagree with our manager? An anonymous bloke on the internet that's who! Kevin Phillips should of scored from a cross that came in from Taylor's side and Matt Phillips was finding it too easy to pick up the ball from long clearences. And no Andrew, you don't get extra points for looking a bit battleworn at the end; you are not Terry Butcher. - 6

Smith - There must have been an orphange fire some where that he had to attend to, hence the feigned injury. - 7

Whittingham - The usual sweetness from his meillifluous left despite some nasty treatment from Holloway's cowards. Having Whittingham play for you must be like being married to Michael-Angelo and trying to remember what it was like when your bathroom ceiling was painted brilliant white like everyone else's. - 9

Gunnarson - Dogged play but still some way from his best. Needs to slim down and regain some agility. Mutch will stroll back into the team - 6

Noone - This will happen a lot this season: Noone gets the ball and sets off on a mazy run, four defenders close in to gawp at his trickery, the ball is played back to Whittingham who spins it out to an unmarked Smith/Bellamy/McNaughton advancing into the area. Noone was easily as much of a threat as Matt Philips has ever been but also won a lot of ball, tracking back and nicking it off the toes of unsuspecting Blackpool players. - 9

Helguson - First spotted being too slow when played in by Bellamy, next spotted going off. Not as good as Mason. - 6

Bellamy - The reason Holloway will never get a job at a top club was shown today with his handling of Bellamy- he did nothing to stop him and it cost the thick worzel git. Bellamy had far too much space to run into both when playing up front and later on when he went wide. Dangerous with the ball he led our defending from the front, constantly pressing and harrassing Blackpool when they tried to pointlessly Swansea it around the back four - 9

Mason - I think he's better than Helguson. - 8

Kim - Err, umm, not quite the home debut we'd all hoped for. Played one sweet ball to Mason but otherwise looked a bit off standard. - 5

Cowie - Not on for very long but he kicked some one who deserved to be kicked.

The officials - If you win you generally love the ref but not today. Whitts was twice caught late without mention. Yes the ref played advantage but both challenges were so late they were easy advantages to play and the players should have been booked when the ball went dead. Both #3 and #6 should have already been on bookings when they were eventually booked. The linesman on the Ninian side was little better. Severl obvious throw-ins went the wrong way and they missed an obvious corner for Blackpool and then gave us one straight after that was clearly a goal kick. - 3
G-ster
G-ster
Club Legend
Club Legend
Posts : 1717
User Points : 5923
Posting Flair : 460
Join date : 2012-06-14
Location : Taffs Well

PostG-ster Sun Sep 30, 2012 6:44 am

Couldn't argue with that.

I definitely think Helguson is lucky to be in the starting XI. Won a few headers but not much else.
Arkay Dubya
Arkay Dubya
Global Superstar
Global Superstar
Posts : 8996
User Points : 28232
Posting Flair : 1906
Join date : 2012-06-15
Age : 104
Location : Here, there, everywhere
http://westerneyes.smugmug.com/

PostArkay Dubya Sun Sep 30, 2012 6:52 am

Kamuza wrote:Marshall - I don't remember Blackpool having a shot on target so I'll assume he knew that free kick was going to hit the post and that's way it looked like it had him beaten all ways up. - 7

McNauhgton - Blackpool are a tough team for any full back to play and Ince being out made Super-Kev's day a bit easier than it might have been. One piece of classic McNaughton covering and some nice support of the attack - 7

Connolly - You score twice you get a good rating but today Connolly looked the equal of Hudson as a defender. Very good performance. - 9

Hudson - it is a bit daft to get booked in the last minute of 3-0 win. The clean sheet bonus must be good. - 7

Taylor - Malky singled him out for praise and who am I to disagree with our manager? An anonymous bloke on the internet that's who! Kevin Phillips should of scored from a cross that came in from Taylor's side and Matt Phillips was finding it too easy to pick up the ball from long clearences. And no Andrew, you don't get extra points for looking a bit battleworn at the end; you are not Terry Butcher. - 6

Smith - There must have been an orphange fire some where that he had to attend to, hence the feigned injury. - 7

Whittingham - The usual sweetness from his meillifluous left despite some nasty treatment from Holloway's cowards. Having Whittingham play for you must be like being married to Michael-Angelo and trying to remember what it was like when your bathroom ceiling was painted brilliant white like everyone else's. - 9

Gunnarson - Dogged play but still some way from his best. Needs to slim down and regain some agility. Mutch will stroll back into the team - 6

Noone - This will happen a lot this season: Noone gets the ball and sets off on a mazy run, four defenders close in to gawp at his trickery, the ball is played back to Whittingham who spins it out to an unmarked Smith/Bellamy/McNaughton advancing into the area. Noone was easily as much of a threat as Matt Philips has ever been but also won a lot of ball, tracking back and nicking it off the toes of unsuspecting Blackpool players. - 9

Helguson - First spotted being too slow when played in by Bellamy, next spotted going off. Not as good as Mason. - 6

Bellamy - The reason Holloway will never get a job at a top club was shown today with his handling of Bellamy- he did nothing to stop him and it cost the thick worzel git. Bellamy had far too much space to run into both when playing up front and later on when he went wide. Dangerous with the ball he led our defending from the front, constantly pressing and harrassing Blackpool when they tried to pointlessly Swansea it around the back four - 9

Mason - I think he's better than Helguson. - 8

Kim - Err, umm, not quite the home debut we'd all hoped for. Played one sweet ball to Mason but otherwise looked a bit off standard. - 5

Cowie - Not on for very long but he kicked some one who deserved to be kicked.

The officials - If you win you generally love the ref but not today. Whitts was twice caught late without mention. Yes the ref played advantage but both challenges were so late they were easy advantages to play and the players should have been booked when the ball went dead. Both #3 and #6 should have already been on bookings when they were eventually booked. The linesman on the Ninian side was little better. Severl obvious throw-ins went the wrong way and they missed an obvious corner for Blackpool and then gave us one straight after that was clearly a goal kick. - 3

This is how I will always describe Whitts from now on. Top rating there Sir, I give you an 8/10 and some flair.
Alf Red
Alf Red
Squad Player
Squad Player
Posts : 89
User Points : 286
Posting Flair : 10
Join date : 2012-06-26

PostAlf Red Sun Sep 30, 2012 7:19 am

Very harsh on Gunnarson and Taylor in my view. Both played very well. Sounds to me as if you have preconceived ideas about those players
Kamuza
Kamuza
International Call-Up
International Call-Up
Posts : 973
User Points : 4084
Posting Flair : 832
Join date : 2012-06-22

PostKamuza Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:25 am

Alf Red wrote:Very harsh on Gunnarson and Taylor in my view. Both played very well. Sounds to me as if you have preconceived ideas about those players

Not at all. I am a huge fan of Gunnarson in particular but today he played like a run of the mill Championship midfielder. He can play much better and I expect him to return to form this season and give Malky a selection headache but right now he is some way behind Much.
Arkay Dubya
Arkay Dubya
Global Superstar
Global Superstar
Posts : 8996
User Points : 28232
Posting Flair : 1906
Join date : 2012-06-15
Age : 104
Location : Here, there, everywhere
http://westerneyes.smugmug.com/

PostArkay Dubya Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:34 am

Dave Jones agrees. He also says we should drop both and sign Gavin Rae back.

Let's rate those players Jones10
Kamuza
Kamuza
International Call-Up
International Call-Up
Posts : 973
User Points : 4084
Posting Flair : 832
Join date : 2012-06-22

PostKamuza Sun Sep 30, 2012 11:16 am

I'll say this for Gavin Rae, when we were down to him and Wildiq in midfield and Rae was carrying an injury he did always manage to play. I don't know that he was taking pain killing injections to play but i believe he was and that is enough for me to point out that Jay Bothroyd might have followed suit for the play off final, the big girl.
Arkay Dubya
Arkay Dubya
Global Superstar
Global Superstar
Posts : 8996
User Points : 28232
Posting Flair : 1906
Join date : 2012-06-15
Age : 104
Location : Here, there, everywhere
http://westerneyes.smugmug.com/

PostArkay Dubya Sun Sep 30, 2012 11:24 am

I actually quite liked Gavin Rae. An unfussy hard-working player, not the most talented but useful at a certain level.

That Jay Bothroyd though... Let's rate those players 904430666
Tyrion Tannister
Tyrion Tannister
Global Superstar
Global Superstar
Posts : 5652
User Points : 18418
Posting Flair : 1090
Join date : 2012-06-26

PostTyrion Tannister Sun Sep 30, 2012 7:53 pm

Sigh...I picked a bad week to drop Bellamy and replace him with Mackail-Smith didn't I? Ill see what happens next week then I might be forced to eat humble pie and put him back in.
Rhys
Rhys
Global Superstar
Global Superstar
Posts : 9525
User Points : 35015
Posting Flair : 2229
Join date : 2012-06-12
Age : 39
http://www.redbluebirds.com

PostRhys Sun Sep 30, 2012 9:01 pm

Red614 wrote:Sigh...I picked a bad week to drop Bellamy and replace him with Mackail-Smith didn't I? Ill see what happens next week then I might be forced to eat humble pie and put him back in.
You get to make a retain number food transfers. I don't know, but I don't think he will play or score reguarly enough to demand a space.
*** G L O V E S ***
*** G L O V E S ***
National Legend
National Legend
Posts : 2749
User Points : 8492
Posting Flair : 721
Join date : 2012-06-15
Age : 31
Location : Way-als
http://danlewis92.weebly.com/

Post*** G L O V E S *** Sun Sep 30, 2012 9:50 pm

Bellamy, Noone and Whittingham were all unbelievable again yesterday. Those three will take us up.
Arkay Dubya
Arkay Dubya
Global Superstar
Global Superstar
Posts : 8996
User Points : 28232
Posting Flair : 1906
Join date : 2012-06-15
Age : 104
Location : Here, there, everywhere
http://westerneyes.smugmug.com/

PostArkay Dubya Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:11 pm

Don't forget your performance too Gloves - we're all counting on you this season.
Valley Trash
Valley Trash
Global Superstar
Global Superstar
Posts : 5471
User Points : 19382
Posting Flair : 1933
Join date : 2012-06-16
Location : Too close to home

PostValley Trash Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:19 pm

Arkay v2.0 wrote:Don't forget your performance too Gloves - we're all counting on you this season.

More important for automatic promotion than Marshall's gloves IMO... I did laugh yestday when the Blackpool free kick hit the bar/post and Marshall caressed the upright Let's rate those players 692773407 There are not many boards where you can post "caressed the upright" without being banned Let's rate those players 692773407
Valley Trash
Valley Trash
Global Superstar
Global Superstar
Posts : 5471
User Points : 19382
Posting Flair : 1933
Join date : 2012-06-16
Location : Too close to home

PostValley Trash Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:22 pm

Kamuza wrote:Marshall - I don't remember Blackpool having a shot on target so I'll assume he knew that free kick was going to hit the post and that's way it looked like it had him beaten all ways up. - 7

McNauhgton - Blackpool are a tough team for any full back to play and Ince being out made Super-Kev's day a bit easier than it might have been. One piece of classic McNaughton covering and some nice support of the attack - 7

Connolly - You score twice you get a good rating but today Connolly looked the equal of Hudson as a defender. Very good performance. - 9

Hudson - it is a bit daft to get booked in the last minute of 3-0 win. The clean sheet bonus must be good. - 7

Taylor - Malky singled him out for praise and who am I to disagree with our manager? An anonymous bloke on the internet that's who! Kevin Phillips should of scored from a cross that came in from Taylor's side and Matt Phillips was finding it too easy to pick up the ball from long clearences. And no Andrew, you don't get extra points for looking a bit battleworn at the end; you are not Terry Butcher. - 6

Smith - There must have been an orphange fire some where that he had to attend to, hence the feigned injury. - 7

Whittingham - The usual sweetness from his meillifluous left despite some nasty treatment from Holloway's cowards. Having Whittingham play for you must be like being married to Michael-Angelo and trying to remember what it was like when your bathroom ceiling was painted brilliant white like everyone else's. - 9

Gunnarson - Dogged play but still some way from his best. Needs to slim down and regain some agility. Mutch will stroll back into the team - 6

Noone - This will happen a lot this season: Noone gets the ball and sets off on a mazy run, four defenders close in to gawp at his trickery, the ball is played back to Whittingham who spins it out to an unmarked Smith/Bellamy/McNaughton advancing into the area. Noone was easily as much of a threat as Matt Philips has ever been but also won a lot of ball, tracking back and nicking it off the toes of unsuspecting Blackpool players. - 9

Helguson - First spotted being too slow when played in by Bellamy, next spotted going off. Not as good as Mason. - 6

Bellamy - The reason Holloway will never get a job at a top club was shown today with his handling of Bellamy- he did nothing to stop him and it cost the thick worzel git. Bellamy had far too much space to run into both when playing up front and later on when he went wide. Dangerous with the ball he led our defending from the front, constantly pressing and harrassing Blackpool when they tried to pointlessly Swansea it around the back four - 9

Mason - I think he's better than Helguson. - 8

Kim - Err, umm, not quite the home debut we'd all hoped for. Played one sweet ball to Mason but otherwise looked a bit off standard. - 5

Cowie - Not on for very long but he kicked some one who deserved to be kicked.

The officials - If you win you generally love the ref but not today. Whitts was twice caught late without mention. Yes the ref played advantage but both challenges were so late they were easy advantages to play and the players should have been booked when the ball went dead. Both #3 and #6 should have already been on bookings when they were eventually booked. The linesman on the Ninian side was little better. Severl obvious throw-ins went the wrong way and they missed an obvious corner for Blackpool and then gave us one straight after that was clearly a goal kick. - 3

Thanks Kamuza a very entertaining, accurate and intelligent assessment of yesterday's performance Let's rate those players 1525230823 Let's rate those players 833362651
Arkay Dubya
Arkay Dubya
Global Superstar
Global Superstar
Posts : 8996
User Points : 28232
Posting Flair : 1906
Join date : 2012-06-15
Age : 104
Location : Here, there, everywhere
http://westerneyes.smugmug.com/

PostArkay Dubya Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:32 pm

Valley Trash wrote:
Arkay v2.0 wrote:Don't forget your performance too Gloves - we're all counting on you this season.

More important for automatic promotion than Marshall's gloves IMO... I did laugh yestday when the Blackpool free kick hit the bar/post and Marshall caressed the upright Let's rate those players 692773407 There are not many boards where you can post "caressed the upright" without being banned Let's rate those players 692773407

My mouse is hovering over the 'Report an abuse' option in the bottom corner but then I realised it's probably a self-abuse, so that's ok...I think.
Sponsored content

PostSponsored content

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

Create an account or log in to leave a reply

You need to be a member in order to leave a reply.

Create an account

Join our community by creating a new account. It's easy!


Create a new account

Log in

Already have an account? No problem, log in here.


Log in

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum