For comparison: South Wales Echo player ratings

Make of these what you will...
David Marshall 6
Matt Connolly 7
Ben Nugent 7
Ben Turner 7
Andrew Taylor 7
Craig Conway 6
Aron Gunnarsson 8
Peter Whittingham 6
Tommy Smith 7
Heidar Helguson 5
Fraizer Campbell 8

I do wonder what match Terry Phillips watched

Philips knows and works with the players, he can't be too critical. Or he's not a fan and therefore not as emotionally invested and reactive as we are.

Kamuza wrote:Philips knows and works with the players, he can't be too critical. Or he's not a fan and therefore not as emotionally invested and reactive as we are.

My rating would have been.

David Marshall 6
Matt Connolly 7
Ben Nugent 6
Ben Turner 6
Andrew Taylor 7
Craig Conway 8
Aron Gunnarsson 6
Peter Whittingham 4
Tommy Smith 6
Heidar Helguson 7
Fraizer Campbell 7

Malky - 4